When I spoke at the Writers’ Institute at UW-Madison, one of my topics was why critiquing is necessary. My presentation included defining the difference between criticism and critique:
I represented CRITICISM with scissor blades facing the recipient — putting a person on the defensive. We typically react (knee-jerk) to this style of communication, viewing it as an attack. Criticism is problem-oriented, negative, and critical.
I represented CRITIQUE with scissor handles facing the recipient — putting the person at ease. We typically respond (thought-filled) to this style of communication, viewing it as a gift. Critique is solution-oriented, positive, and helpful.
When you provide feedback (at home, work, or in a writing situation), is your message respectful, honest, useful, clear, and specific?
“Whatever you are not changing, you are choosing.”
— Laurie Buchanan
© 2013 Laurie Buchanan – All Rights Reserved
Find me on Twitter @HolEssence